warning.rng

OpenSSL Source code for SFTP, SSH, and many others

This document contains a description of portable OpenSSH's random
number collection code. An alternate reading of this text could
well be titled "Why I should pressure my system vendor to supply
/dev/random in their OS".

Why is this important? OpenSSH depends on good, unpredictable numbers
for generating keys, performing digital signatures and forming
cryptographic challenges. If the random numbers that it uses are
predictable, then the strength of the whole system is compromised.

A particularly pernicious problem arises with DSA keys (used by the
ssh2 protocol). Performing a DSA signature (which is required for
authentication), entails the use of a 160 bit random number.  If an
attacker can predict this number, then they can deduce your *private*
key and impersonate you or your hosts.

If you are using the builtin random number support (configure will
tell you if this is the case), then read this document in its entirety.
Alternately, you can use Lutz Jaenicke's PRNGd - a small daemon which
collects random numbers and makes them available by a socket.

Please also request that your OS vendor provides a kernel-based random
number collector (/dev/random) in future versions of your operating
systems by default.

On to the description...

The portable OpenSSH contains random number collection support for
systems which lack a kernel entropy pool (/dev/random).

This collector (as of 3.1 and beyond) comes as an external application
that allows the local admin to decide on how to implement entropy
collection.

The default entropy collector operates by executing the programs listed
in ($etcdir)/ssh_prng_cmds, reading their output and adding it to the
PRNG supplied by OpenSSL (which is hash-based). It also stirs in the
output of several system calls and timings from the execution of the
programs that it runs.

The ssh_prng_cmds file also specifies a 'rate' for each program. This
represents the number of bits of randomness per byte of output from
the specified program.

The random number code will also read and save a seed file to
~/.ssh/prng_seed. This contents of this file are added to the random
number generator at startup. The goal here is to maintain as much 
randomness between sessions as possible.

The default entropy collection code has two main problems:

1. It is slow.

Executing each program in the list can take a large amount of time,   
especially on slower machines. Additionally some program can take a   
disproportionate time to execute.                                     

Tuning the default entropy collection code is difficult at this point.
It requires doing 'times ./ssh-rand-helper'  and modifying the
($etcdir)/ssh_prng_cmds until you have found the issue.  In the next
release we will be looking at support '-v' for verbose output to allow
easier debugging.

The default entropy collector will timeout programs which take too long
to execute, the actual timeout used can be adjusted with the
--with-entropy-timeout configure option. OpenSSH will not try to
re-execute programs which have not been found, have had a non-zero
exit status or have timed out more than a couple of times.

2. Estimating the real 'rate' of program outputs is non-trivial

The shear volume of the task is problematic: there are currently
around 50 commands in the ssh_prng_cmds list, portable OpenSSH
supports at least 12 different OSs. That is already 600 sets of data
to be analysed, without taking into account the numerous differences
between versions of each OS.

On top of this, the different commands can produce varying amounts of
usable data depending on how busy the machine is, how long it has been
up and various other factors.

To make matters even more complex, some of the commands are reporting
largely the same data as other commands (eg. the various "ps" calls).


How to avoid the default entropy code?

The best way is to read the OpenSSL documentation and recompile OpenSSL
to use prngd or egd.  Some platforms (like earily solaris) have 3rd
party /dev/random devices that can be also used for this task.

If you are forced to use ssh-rand-helper consider still downloading
prngd/egd and configure OpenSSH using --with-prngd-port=xx or
--with-prngd-socket=xx (refer to INSTALL for more information).

$Id: WARNING.RNG,v 1.5 2002/04/14 13:16:05 djm Exp $