rfc1237.ps

著名的RFC文档,其中有一些文档是已经翻译成中文的的.

(backbone\))g(domain,)h(and)e(which)h(use)g(that)f(regional)g(for)h(all)g
(external)g(\(inter)o(-)0 1142 y(domain\))d(traf)o(\256c.)31
b(A)16 b(small)f(address)h(pre\256x)g(may)f(be)h(assigned)f(to)h(the)f
(regional,)i(which)f(then)f(assigns)g(slightly)0 1198 y(longer)i(pre\256xes)h
(\(based)f(on)g(the)g(regional')m(s)g(pre\256x\))h(to)f(each)h(of)f(the)g
(routing)f(domains)g(that)h(it)f(interconnects.)0 1254 y(This)e(allows)g(the)
h(regional,)g(when)g(informing)f(other)g(routing)g(domains)g(of)g(the)h
(addresses)g(that)f(it)g(can)i(reach,)g(to)0 1311 y(abbreviate)e(the)g
(reachability)f(information)g(for)h(a)g(lar)o(ge)g(number)g(of)g(routing)e
(domains)h(as)h(a)g(single)f(pre\256x.)25 b(This)0 1367 y(approach)9
b(therefore)h(can)f(allow)f(a)h(great)g(deal)g(of)g(hierarchical)g
(abbreviation)f(of)h(routing)f(information,)g(and)h(thereby)0
1424 y(can)j(greatly)f(improve)g(the)g(scalability)f(of)h(inter)o(-domain)g
(routing.)0 1530 y(Clearly)m(,)h(this)d(approach)i(is)f(recursive)h(and)f
(can)h(be)g(carried)g(through)e(several)i(iterations.)16 b(Routing)9
b(domains)h(at)g(any)0 1587 y(\252level\272)k(in)g(the)g(hierarchy)g(may)g
(use)g(their)g(pre\256x)h(as)f(the)g(basis)f(for)h(subsequent)f
(suballocations,)h(assuming)f(that)0 1643 y(the)h(NSAP)g(addresses)g(remain)f
(within)g(the)g(overall)h(length)f(and)g(structure)h(constraints.)23
b(The)13 b(GOSIP)i(V)-5 b(ersion)13 b(2)0 1699 y(NSAP)f(structure,)g
(discussed)e(later)i(in)f(this)f(section,)h(allows)g(for)h(multiple)d(levels)
i(of)h(routing)e(hierarchy)m(.)0 1806 y(At)16 b(this)e(point,)j(we)f(observe)
g(that)f(the)h(number)f(of)h(nodes)g(at)g(each)g(lower)g(level)g(of)g(a)g
(hierarchy)g(tends)g(to)f(grow)0 1862 y(exponentially)m(.)43
b(Thus)19 b(the)h(greatest)h(gains)f(in)g(data)g(abstraction)g(occur)h(at)f
(the)g(leaves)h(and)f(the)g(gains)g(drop)0 1919 y(signi\256cantly)d(at)i
(each)g(higher)g(level.)38 b(Therefore,)22 b(the)c(law)h(of)f(diminishing)e
(returns)j(suggests)e(that)h(at)h(some)0 1975 y(point)13 b(data)h
(abstraction)f(ceases)i(to)e(produce)h(signi\256cant)f(bene\256ts.)24
b(Determination)13 b(of)h(the)g(point)f(at)g(which)h(data)0
2032 y(abstraction)h(ceases)h(to)f(be)h(of)g(bene\256t)f(requires)h(a)g
(careful)g(consideration)f(of)h(the)f(number)g(of)h(routing)e(domains)0
2088 y(that)e(are)i(expected)f(to)f(occur)h(at)g(each)g(level)g(of)g(the)f
(hierarchy)i(\(over)f(a)g(given)f(period)g(of)h(time\),)g(compared)g(to)f
(the)0 2144 y(number)j(of)h(routing)e(domains)g(and)i(address)f(pre\256xes)h
(that)f(can)h(conveniently)e(and)i(ef)o(\256ciently)g(be)f(handled)g(via)0
2201 y(dynamic)c(inter)o(-domain)f(routing)g(protocols.)0 2307
y(There)i(is)e(a)i(balance)f(that)g(must)f(be)h(sought)f(between)h(the)g
(requirements)f(on)h(NSAPs)h(for)f(ef)o(\256cient)h(routing)e(and)h(the)0
2364 y(need)h(for)g(decentralized)h(NSAP)g(administration.)j(The)c(NSAP)h
(structure)f(from)f(V)-5 b(ersion)12 b(2)g(of)g(GOSIP)h(\(Figure)f(2\))0
2420 y(of)o(fers)h(an)f(example)g(of)g(how)f(these)h(two)g(needs)g(might)e
(be)i(met.)19 b(The)12 b(AFI,)h(IDI,)f(DFI,)h(and)f(AA)g(\256elds)g(provide)g
(for)0 2477 y(administrative)c(decentralization.)17 b(The)10
b(AFI/IDI)h(pair)f(of)g(values)g(47/0005)f(identify)g(the)h(U.S.)i
(government)d(as)h(the)0 2533 y(authority)g(responsible)h(for)g(de\256ning)g
(the)g(DSP)h(structure)g(and)f(allocating)f(values)h(within)f(it)h(\(see)h
(Appendix)e(A)i(for)0 2678 y(Colella,)g(Gardner)n(,)g(&)f(Callon)1220
b([Page)12 b(12])p eop
%%Page: 13 13
bop 0 50 a Fi(RFC)13 b(1237)281 b(Guidelines)10 b(for)i(OSI)g(NSAP)g
(Allocation)e(in)h(the)g(Internet)293 b(July)11 b(1991)0 195
y(more)g(information)f(on)h(NSAP)h(structure\).)195 334 y([Note:)28
b(It)18 b(is)f(not)g(important)f(that)h(NSAPs)h(be)g(allocated)f(from)g(the)h
(GOSIP)g(V)-5 b(ersion)17 b(2)195 391 y(authority)12 b(under)i(47/0005.)21
b(The)14 b(ANSI)f(format)h(under)f(the)g(Data)h(Country)f(Code)h(for)f(the)
195 447 y(U.S.)19 b(\(DCC=840\))f(and)g(formats)f(assigned)g(to)h(other)f
(countries)h(and)f(ISO)i(members)e(or)195 504 y(liaison)10
b(or)o(ganizations)g(are)i(also)e(expected)i(to)e(be)i(used,)f(and)g(will)f
(work)h(equally)f(well.)17 b(For)195 560 y(parts)12 b(of)f(the)h(Internet)g
(outside)e(of)i(the)g(U.S.)g(there)g(may)g(in)f(some)g(cases)h(be)g(strong)f
(reasons)195 616 y(to)f(prefer)i(a)f(local)g(format)f(rather)h(than)g(the)f
(GOSIP)i(format.)k(However)n(,)c(GOSIP)g(addresses)195 673
y(are)g(used)f(in)g(most)f(cases)i(in)f(the)g(examples)g(in)g(this)g(paper)g
(because:)263 767 y Fc(\017)23 b Fi(The)11 b(DSP)h(format)f(has)h(been)f
(de\256ned)h(and)f(allows)g(hierarchical)h(allocation;)e(and,)263
861 y Fc(\017)23 b Fi(An)14 b(operational)g(registration)f(authority)h(for)h
(suballocation)e(of)h(AA)h(values)f(under)309 917 y(the)d(GOSIP)h(address)g
(space)f(has)h(already)f(been)h(established)e(at)i(GSA.])0
1082 y(GOSIP)i(V)-5 b(ersion)12 b(2)h(de\256nes)h(the)f(DSP)g(structure)g(as)
g(shown)f(\(under)i(DFI=80h\))f(and)g(provides)f(for)h(the)g(allocation)0
1138 y(of)f(AA)g(values)f(to)h(administrations.)k(Thus,)11
b(the)h(\256elds)g(from)g(the)f(AFI)i(to)e(the)h(AA,)g(inclusive,)f
(represent)i(a)f(unique)0 1195 y(address)f(pre\256x)h(assigned)f(to)g(an)g
(administration.)p 429 1304 293 2 v 428 1359 2 57 v 453 1342
a Fc( )-8 b(\000)13 b Fi(IDP)f Fc(\000)-7 b(!)p 720 1359 V
429 1361 1190 2 v 428 1415 2 57 v 453 1398 a Fi(AFI)p 551 1415
V 79 w(IDI)p 720 1415 V 375 w Fc( )f(\000)13 b Fi(DSP)f Fc(\000)-7
b(!)p 1617 1415 V 429 1417 1190 2 v 428 1472 2 57 v 463 1455
a Fa(47)p 551 1472 V 65 w(0005)p 720 1472 V 56 w(DFI)p 852
1472 V 51 w(AA)p 957 1472 V 51 w(Rsvd)p 1116 1472 V 51 w(RD)p
1221 1472 V 51 w(Area)p 1380 1472 V 51 w(ID)p 1485 1472 V 51
w(Sel)p 1617 1472 V 429 1473 1190 2 v 297 1511 a Fi(octets)p
428 1528 2 57 v 75 w(1)p 551 1528 V 123 w(2)p 720 1528 V 128
w(1)p 852 1528 V 95 w(3)p 957 1528 V 109 w(2)p 1116 1528 V
109 w(2)p 1221 1528 V 109 w(2)p 1380 1528 V 109 w(6)p 1485
1528 V 95 w(1)p 1617 1528 V 429 1530 1190 2 v 585 1628 a(IDP)70
b(Initial)11 b(Domain)f(Part)585 1685 y(AFI)70 b(Authority)10
b(and)i(Format)f(Identi\256er)585 1741 y(IDI)80 b(Initial)11
b(Domain)f(Identi\256er)585 1798 y(DSP)60 b(Domain)11 b(Speci\256c)h(Part)585
1854 y(DFI)70 b(DSP)12 b(Format)g(Identi\256er)585 1911 y(AA)77
b(Administrative)10 b(Authority)585 1967 y(Rsvd)49 b(Reserved)585
2024 y(RD)80 b(Routing)11 b(Domain)f(Identi\256er)585 2080
y(Area)55 b(Area)12 b(Identi\256er)585 2137 y(ID)95 b(System)11
b(Identi\256er)585 2193 y(SEL)62 b(NSAP)12 b(Selector)540 2336
y(Figure)f(2:)16 b(GOSIP)d(V)-5 b(ersion)11 b(2)g(NSAP)h(structure.)0
2441 y(Currently)m(,)17 b(a)e(proposal)g(is)g(being)f(progressed)h(in)g(ANSI)
h(for)g(an)f(American)g(National)g(Standard)h(\(ANS\))g(for)f(the)0
2497 y(DSP)h(of)e(the)h(NSAP)h(address)e(space)i(administered)d(by)i(ANSI.)g
(This)f(will)g(provide)h(an)g(identical)f(DSP)h(structure)0
2554 y(to)e(that)h(provided)f(by)g(GOSIP)i(V)-5 b(ersion)13
b(2.)24 b(The)14 b(ANSI)g(format,)h(therefore,)g(dif)o(fers)g(from)e(that)h
(illustrated)e(above)0 2678 y(Colella,)g(Gardner)n(,)g(&)f(Callon)1220
b([Page)12 b(13])p eop
%%Page: 14 14
bop 0 50 a Fi(RFC)13 b(1237)281 b(Guidelines)10 b(for)i(OSI)g(NSAP)g
(Allocation)e(in)h(the)g(Internet)293 b(July)11 b(1991)0 195
y(only)i(in)h(that)f(the)h(IDP)h(is)e(based)h(on)g(an)g(ISO)g(DCC)h
(assignment,)f(and)g(in)f(that)h(the)f(AA)h(will)f(be)h(administered)f(by)0
252 y(a)h(dif)o(ferent)h(or)o(ganization)e(\(ANSI)i(secretariat)g(instead)e
(of)h(GSA\).)h(The)f(technical)g(considerations)f(applicable)g(to)0
308 y(NSAP)h(administration)d(are)i(independent)g(of)g(whether)g(a)g(GOSIP)h
(V)-5 b(ersion)12 b(2)h(or)g(an)g(ANSI)h(value)f(is)f(used)h(for)g(the)0
364 y(NSAP)f(assignment.)0 471 y(Similarly)m(,)h(although)e(other)i
(countries)f(may)g(make)h(use)f(of)h(slightly)e(dif)o(ferent)i(NSAP)h
(formats,)f(the)f(principles)g(of)0 527 y(NSAP)g(assignment)e(and)h(use)h
(are)g(the)f(same.)0 633 y(In)i(the)g(low-order)g(part)f(of)h(the)g(GOSIP)h
(V)-5 b(ersion)12 b(2)h(NSAP)h(format,)f(two)f(\256elds)h(are)h(de\256ned)f
(in)g(addition)e(to)i(those)0 690 y(required)k(by)f(DIS10589.)31
b(These)16 b(\256elds,)i(RD)f(and)f(Area,)j(are)e(de\256ned)g(to)f(allow)g
(allocation)f(of)i(NSAPs)g(along)0 746 y(topological)12 b(boundaries)h(in)g
(support)g(of)g(increased)h(data)g(abstraction.)23 b(Administrations)11
b(assign)h(RD)i(identi\256ers)0 803 y(underneath)g(their)f(unique)h(address)f
(pre\256x)i(\(the)f(reserved)g(\256eld)g(is)g(left)g(to)f(accommodate)g
(future)h(growth)g(and)f(to)0 859 y(provide)f(additional)e(\257exibility)h
(for)h(inter)o(-domain)f(routing\).)18 b(Routing)12 b(domains)f(allocate)h
(Area)g(identi\256ers)g(from)0 916 y(their)f(unique)g(pre\256x.)17
b(The)12 b(result)f(is:)68 1072 y Fc(\017)23 b Fi(AFI+IDI+DFI+AA)12
b(=)f(administration)e(pre\256x,)68 1166 y Fc(\017)23 b Fi(administration)9
b(pre\256x\(+Rsvd\)+RD)j(=)f(routing)g(domain)f(pre\256x,)i(and,)68
1259 y Fc(\017)23 b Fi(routing)10 b(domain)g(pre\256x+Area)j(=)e(area)h
(address.)0 1416 y(This)d(provides)h(for)g(summarization)f(of)h(all)g(area)h
(addresses)f(within)f(a)i(routing)e(domain)g(into)g(one)h(pre\256x.)17
b(If)11 b(the)f(AA)0 1472 y(identi\256er)i(is)g(accorded)i(topological)d
(signi\256cance)i(\(in)f(addition)f(to)h(administrative)f(signi\256cance\),)j
(an)e(additional)0 1528 y(level)f(of)h(data)f(abstraction)g(can)h(be)f
(obtained,)g(as)h(is)f(discussed)f(in)h(the)g(next)g(section.)0
1725 y Ff(5)58 b(NSAP)14 b(Administration)j(and)e(Routing)h(in)f(the)g
(Internet)0 1878 y Fi(Internet)10 b(routing)f(components\320backbones,)g
(regionals,)h(and)g(sites)g(or)g(campuses\320are)g(arranged)h(hierarchically)
0 1934 y(for)c(the)g(most)g(part.)15 b(A)7 b(natural)g(mapping)g(from)g
(these)g(components)g(to)g(OSI)g(routing)g(com)o(ponents)f(is)h(that)g
(backbones,)0 1991 y(regionals,)j(and)g(sites)f(act)i(as)f(routing)f
(domains.)15 b(\(Alternatively)m(,)10 b(a)g(site)g(may)f(choose)h(to)g
(operate)g(as)g(an)g(area)h(within)0 2047 y(a)h(regional.)19
b(However)n(,)13 b(in)f(such)g(a)g(case)h(the)f(area)h(is)f(part)g(of)g(the)g
(regional')m(s)g(routing)g(domain)f(and)h(the)g(discussion)0
2104 y(in)e(Section)h(5.1)f(applies.)16 b(W)l(e)11 b(assume)f(that)g(some,)h
(if)f(not)g(most,)g(sites)g(will)f(prefer)j(to)e(operate)h(as)f(routing)g
(domains.)0 2160 y(By)15 b(operating)f(as)h(a)g(routing)e(domain,)i(a)g(site)
f(operates)h(a)g(level)f(2)g(subdomain)f(as)i(well)f(as)h(one)g(or)f(more)h
(level)f(1)0 2217 y(areas.\))0 2323 y(Given)d(such)f(a)i(mapping,)e(where)h
(should)f(address)h(administration)e(and)i(allocation)f(be)h(performed)g(to)g
(satisfy)f(both)0 2379 y(administrative)g(decentralization)h(and)g(data)h
(abstraction?)k(Three)c(possibilities)c(are)k(considered:)57
2523 y(1.)23 b(at)11 b(the)g(area,)0 2678 y(Colella,)h(Gardner)n(,)g(&)f
(Callon)1220 b([Page)12 b(14])p eop
%%Page: 15 15
bop 0 50 a Fi(RFC)13 b(1237)281 b(Guidelines)10 b(for)i(OSI)g(NSAP)g
(Allocation)e(in)h(the)g(Internet)293 b(July)11 b(1991)57 195
y(2.)23 b(at)11 b(the)g(leaf)h(routing)e(domain,)h(and,)57
289 y(3.)23 b(at)11 b(the)g(transit)g(routing)f(domain)h(\(TRD\).)0
433 y(Leaf)h(routing)e(domains)g(correspond)i(to)e(sites,)h(where)h(the)f
(primary)g(purpose)g(is)g(to)g(provide)g(intra-domain)f(routing)0
489 y(services.)17 b(T)n(ransit)9 b(routing)g(domains)g(are)i(deployed)f(to)f
(carry)i(transit)f(\(i.e.,)h(inter)o(-domain\))f(traf)o(\256c;)h(backbones)f
(and)0 545 y(regionals)h(are)h(TRDs.)0 652 y(The)k(greatest)g(burden)g(in)g
(transmitting)e(and)i(operating)g(on)g(routing)f(information)g(is)g(at)h(the)
g(top)g(of)g(the)g(routing)0 708 y(hierarchy)m(,)e(where)f(routing)f
(information)g(tends)g(to)g(accumulate.)21 b(In)13 b(the)g(Internet,)h(for)f
(example,)g(regionals)f(must)0 765 y(manage)f(the)g(set)f(of)h(network)g
(numbers)f(for)h(all)g(networks)f(reachable)i(through)e(the)h(regional.)16
b(T)n(raf)o(\256c)d(destined)d(for)0 821 y(other)i(networks)f(is)h(generally)
g(routed)g(to)g(the)f(backbone.)19 b(The)13 b(backbones,)f(however)n(,)h
(must)e(be)h(cognizant)g(of)g(the)0 878 y(network)f(numbers)g(for)g(all)g
(attached)h(regionals)f(and)g(their)g(associated)g(networks.)0
984 y(In)i(general,)h(the)f(advantage)g(of)g(abstracting)f(routing)g
(information)f(at)i(a)h(given)e(level)h(of)g(the)f(routing)g(hierarchy)i(is)0
1040 y(greater)f(at)f(the)g(higher)g(levels)f(of)h(the)g(hierarchy)m(.)20
b(There)12 b(is)g(relatively)f(little)g(direct)h(bene\256t)h(to)e(the)h
(administration)0 1097 y(that)h(performs)g(the)g(abstraction,)g(since)g(it)g
(must)f(maintain)f(routing)i(information)e(individually)g(on)i(each)h
(attached)0 1153 y(topological)c(routing)g(structure.)0 1259
y(For)f(example,)h(suppose)e(that)g(a)i(given)e(site)g(is)h(trying)f(to)g
(decide)h(whether)g(to)g(obtain)f(an)h(NSAP)h(address)f(pre\256x)g(based)0
1316 y(on)14 b(an)g(AA)g(value)h(from)f(GSA)g(\(implying)f(that)g(the)h
(\256rst)h(four)f(octets)g(of)g(the)g(address)g(would)g(be)g(those)g
(assigned)0 1372 y(out)d(of)g(the)g(GOSIP)i(space\),)f(or)g(based)f(on)g(an)h
(RD)g(value)f(from)g(its)g(regional)g(\(implying)e(that)i(the)h(\256rst)f
(seven)g(octets)0 1429 y(of)j(the)g(address)g(are)h(those)e(assign